Commons Cup Past Winners
- 2022 – West House
- 2021- North House
- 2020- Murray House
- 2019- Sutherland House
- 2018- Memorial House
- 2017- Crawford House
- 2016- Memorial House & Stambaugh House (tie)
- 2015- Murray House
- 2014- North House
- 2013- North House
- 2012- North House
- 2011- Gillette House
- 2010- Gillette House