Does autonomy lead to better schools? Greater autonomy is often claimed to be linked to greater innovation, especially in the debate about charter schools. In a newly released report, the Center on Reinventing Public Education explores the opportunities and challenges of charter schools because of their autonomy.
Inside Charter Schools: Unlocking Doors to Student Success uses multiple data sources including surveys and case studies to address this issue. Charter schools are granted more autonomy than traditional public schools in exchange for more accountability, to school authorizers as well as parents and students. This greater autonomy allows charter school principals and boards to: create their own mission and the curriculum that is best suited to their chosen mission, have more control over hiring policies and staffing, and other focused programs. However, the presence of autonomy does not insure a good school, it is just an opportunity. There are also many challenges that arise from this independence. High staff turnover, limited principal training in enlarged roles and limited support are just some of the challenges confronting these leaders. Overall, the utilization of autonomy is more important than its simple presence.
For more information, check out the paper! A brief is also available for this study.