Home » Notes » Al-Bihani, Not So Charming

Al-Bihani, Not So Charming

PDF · Cara Maureen Walsh · Jul-5-2012 · 43 VAND. J. TRANSNAT'L L. 1151 (2010)

In June 2008, the Supreme Court extended the Suspension Clause to foreign detainees at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba.  Since then, courts have struggled to define appropriate standards to govern detainee habeas corpus petitions.  Until recently, no court questioned the relevance of international law to the development of these standards.  But, in January 2010, a D.C. Circuit panel held that international law does not constrain executive detention power.  That decision could devastate detainee habeas corpus petitions by preventing courts from examining the heart of the government’s own claimed detention authority.

This Note evaluates the proper role of international law during ongoing Guantánamo detainee habeas corpus litigation through an examination of the D.C. Circuit panel’s legal analysis in Al-Bihani v. Obama.  Because international law has always played a role in U.S. jurisprudence, judges already have the necessary tools to grapple with the international legal issues that the detainee cases present.  In light of the Legislature’s refusal to develop appropriate standards to govern these cases, the Judiciary must use these tools to balance national security with individual liberty.




Leave a Reply

ExpressO Top 10 Law Review

ANNOUNCEMENTS

We are pleased to announce the 2013-2014 VJTL New Members

Coming up:

The Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law hosted a symposium called “The Role of Non-State Actors in International Law” at Vanderbilt University Law School in February 2013.

The October issue of the Journal will showcase articles by distinguished symposium guests including:

  • Mr. Ian Smillie, “Blood Diamonds and Non-State Actors”
  • Professor Jean d’Aspremont, “Cognitive Conflicts and the Making of International Law from Empirical Concord to Conceptual Discord in Legal Scholarship”
  • Professor Peter J. Spiro, “Constraining Global Corporate Power: A Very Short Introduction”
  • Professor Suzanne Katzenstein
  • Professor Peter Margulies
  • Professor Harlan G. Cohen

 

Explore Other Vanderbilt Law Resources