Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen and the Filiation
of Economic Ideas
Working Paper No. 00-W18
Andrea Maneschi
ABSTRACT [article]
This article examines the intellectual influences that economists
exerted on Nicholas Georgescu Roegen in his formative and mature years. While these
include Malthus, Marshall, Pareto and Schumpeter, attention is focused on Marx and Gossen.
Karl Marx is the economist whom Georgescu Roegen cited most frequently in his three books.
While criticizing several of Marx's views, he noted approvingly that Marx did not consider
the economic process as an isolated or closed system. This contrasts with its
representation by the neoclassical paradigm, which ignores the absorption of low-entropy
resources from the environment and their transformation into high-entropy waste.
Georgescu Roegen's 130-page essay on "Hermann Heinrich Gossen: His life and work in
historical perspective" was his introduction to the first English-language translation
of Gossen's The Laws of Human Relations and the Rules of Human Action Derived Therefrom.
This allowed Georgescu Roegen to re-evaluate his own early work on consumer theory, and
highlight the importance that Gossen attributed to the role of time in consumer welfare
maximization. It also gave him the opportunity to remark on the fate of a genius like
Gossen, who was totally ignored in his lifetime and later frequently misunderstood.
Georgescu Roegen occupies a secure place in the filiation of economic ideas. His name
is now closely associated with the fields of bioeconomics and ecological economics.