Vanderbilt and Nashville: Working Together for a Better Tomorrow

Remarks by John R. Hall, president, Vanderbilt University Board of Trust
Nashville Rotary Club, April 8, 1996


I am delighted to have this opportunity to visit with you today. While I have lived in Kentucky for most of the last 40 years, in many ways Nashville is home to me. My parents were raised and attended school in Nashville. Dad was a member of the engineering class of 1932 at Vanderbilt, and my mother attended Peabody.

After my parents were married, they lived in Texas and west Tennessee for a while but returned to Nashville during World War II. At that time, my father was personnel manager at the Vultee plant near the airport, which first built fighter-bombers and then P38s as part of the war effort. After the war, my parents moved to Knoxville where I attended Knoxville High School before returning to Nashville and Vanderbilt.

Vanderbilt has been a major influence on my family. Two of my uncles, Bill and Sid Sanders, graduated in 1941 and 1953, respectively. Both married Vanderbilt graduates, and both became bishops in the Episcopal Church. Some of you may know Uncle Bill, who served as the bishop of the Episcopal diocese of Tennessee for many years.

My first wife, Ann McQuiddy, who passed away in 1972, was a Vandy graduate from an old Nashville family that is known to many of you.

Donna Stauffer of Macon, Georgia, and I have been married almost 16 years. While Donna is a graduate of the University of Georgia, she is an avid Vanderbilt supporter. We have one son, John Lipscomb Hall.

The renegade in the family is my brother. Jim currently serves as chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board. Some of you may have known him when he was executive assistant to former Governor McWherter for eight years.

I say Jim's the renegade because he's a lawyer who graduated from the University of Tennessee and who ran the Clinton campaign in Tennessee in 1992. I'm a chemical engineer from Vanderbilt and was the Kentucky finance chairman for the George Bush campaign in 1992. We don't talk much about football or politics at family outings!

Vanderbilt has not only been a major influence on my family, but has played a major role in my life. I was pleased to attend Vanderbilt on a football scholarship and played during the seasons from 1951 through 1954. I played two years under Bill Edwards and two years under Art Guepe. All told, we lost a few more games than we won, but we had a lot of successes also.

We had a winning season in 1951, with Bill Wade at quarterback. In 1952, we upset Florida in Nashville when Florida was undefeated and ranked nationally in the top five. In my last game, we beat Tennessee 26-0, and the Volunteers fired their coach. The next year, 1955, my teammates went to the Gator Bowl and almost won the Southeastern Conference Championship.

I am eternally indebted for the opportunity to attend this wonderful University. Without the football scholarship, it would have been difficult for my parents to send me to Vanderbilt. I was only an average high school student, but with the help of my engineering professors, I graduated magna cum laude. Whatever success I've had, I owe to this great University. In my current endeavors, I hope in some small way I can return to the University a part of what it's done for me.

Nashville and Vanderbilt have been in the headlines a lot in the last few months. Our Mayor's comments in Sports Illustrated drew a lot of attention. In addition, some alumni feel we have forgotten Nashville and really don't care about the University's athletic teams. Today, I would like to discuss these issues in the context of the special relationship between Nashville and Vanderbilt.

In order, I would like to discuss four major points:
· first, Vanderbilt is a big enterprise with unlimited opportunities and plenty of challenges;
· second, Vanderbilt needs Nashville, but Nashville also needs Vanderbilt;
· third, Vanderbilt's record in the past 14 years under the leadership of Chancellor Joe Wyatt has been outstanding by any measure; and
· fourth, I will make a few comments about our athletic committee and our public relations review.

Vanderbilt is a major business
enterprise

Amidst all the news of athletic events, research grants, cultural activities and so on, it is easy to overlook the fact that managing Vanderbilt University is not easy. It is a big business enterprise with all the challenges and opportunities that entails.

No enterprise with an annual operating budget of $900 million could be considered small. The University employs 11,000 people and has a payroll of more than $425 million. Vanderbilt faculty and staff generate more than $69 million in federal, state and local taxes as a direct result of employment. The University itself pays about $2.6 million in state and local taxes.

Vanderbilt also contributed more than $330 million last year to the local economy through the purchase of goods and services. In the last fiscal year alone, the University spent more than $60 million on construction, providing jobs for local workers.

Vanderbilt's 10 colleges and schools attract more than 10,000 students from all 50 states and numerous other countries. These students are served by 3,000 full- and part-time faculty members for a student/full-time-faculty ratio of 11 to 1 - a distinction that puts us in company with Harvard, Yale, the University of Pennsylvania and Northwestern.

Patient visits to the Medical Center total about 500,000 per year, including hospital, emergency room and clinic visits. Last year, the Medical Center provided more than $41 million in charity care - more than all other Nashville hospitals combined.

All told, Vanderbilt's economic impact on Nashville and the surrounding community has been estimated at $1.8 billion.

So Vanderbilt is a big enterprise. That may account for the belief, held by some, that Vanderbilt is "rich." Vanderbilt's current endowment of just over $1 billion does sound large. In fact, I've heard some people say, "Why do they keep asking for money when they already have a big endowment?"

Need for a large endowment

It's a fair question. But let me say to you that Vanderbilt never has enough money to fully accomplish its mission of education and research, and financing the budget every year is not an easy task for the Chancellor and the Board of Trust.

Why do we ask for more money? For one reason, we need new buildings. We need a fine arts center. We have a wonderful art collection that cannot be displayed because we have no place to exhibit it. The engineering building is old and in need of repair. These are just two examples of facility needs; there are many others.

In addition, we need more endowed chairs in order to bring the best and the brightest faculty to our campus. We need more money for research, whether it is in medicine, anthropology or another field. We need more money to provide financial aid so that we can admit more of those students with high academic achievement whose parents cannot afford the University. The list goes on.

The fact is we need a large endowment for Vanderbilt to fulfill its mission as a great university and serve the needs of students, faculty and the surrounding community.

How does Vanderbilt's
endowment compare?

We should also look at our endowment from the perspective of other major private universities. Harvard's endowment of $6.2 billion is six times larger than Vanderbilt's, but its enrollment is not that much greater - 18,500 students. Yale has 11,000 students and 13 schools and is roughly the same size as Vanderbilt, but its endowment is $3.9 billion. Princeton's is $3.9 billion; Stanford's is $3.4 billion; MIT's is slightly over $2 billion. We have a long way to go before we reach those standards.

Ever-increasing demands are being placed on the University. Chancellor Joe Wyatt and his staff have an enormous job to do in running this huge enterprise, and they need the support of everyone in the community if Vanderbilt is to continue in its quest to be the best.

Nashville and Vanderbilt:
Two halves of a
symbiotic whole

Which brings me to my second point: Nashville and Vanderbilt need each other.

Nashville has been home to the University since it was founded in 1873 by Commodore Cornelius Van-derbilt. Approximately 16,000 Vanderbilt alumni live in the Nashville area. Many of Vanderbilt's entering freshmen from outside the city choose this institution because they can attend a first-rate university located in an attractive metropolitan community.

Over the years, Nashville and Vanderbilt have grown together, and we hope that Nashville takes a certain pride in laying claim to one of America's great universities.

The University and its 10 schools are recognized, not just in U.S. News and World Report surveys, but in business, professional and academic networks worldwide. Vanderbilt faculty are quoted by the news media around the nation and the world. Every time The Wall Street Journal or The New York Times quotes a professor from Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee, it raises the prestige of the University and the city. A rising tide does lift all boats.

Nashville and Vanderbilt have enjoyed a long and mutually beneficial relationship. Nashville has been generous to Vanderbilt. You have supported the University with your contributions; sent us the brightest and the best of your young people; provided us excellent business and professional services; provided a high quality of life for our faculty, staff and students; cheered for our athletes; and worked with us to address community problems and seize new opportunities for Nashville.

In short, you have been there for Vanderbilt. By the same token, Vanderbilt has been there for you.

Some of your children may attend Vanderbilt. As just one example of the close ties between the student body and the city, Nashville can take pride in having one of its own, Phil Ayres, who attended Goodpasture School, recently elected as president of the Student Government Association.
Perhaps you or a member of your family has benefited from the Medical Center or your personal physician may be a Vandy graduate. About 30 percent of Vanderbilt's medical and legal alumni stay close to home and practice in Tennessee.

You may have enjoyed the talents of a nationally known artist through the Great Performances at Vanderbilt series.

Many of your school-age children may benefit from the skills of excellent classroom teachers who are Peabody graduates, and some may be touched by the Learning Communities or Day on Campus programs Vanderbilt offers.

These are just a few of the specific ways Vanderbilt is there for the community. Like two halves of a symbiotic whole, Nashville and Vanderbilt serve and need each other and have done so throughout their mutual history.

Fourteen years of progress

Since being named President of the Board of Trust, I have been trying to become even more familiar with Vanderbilt and asked for a comparison of the Vanderbilt of today with the University of the early 1980s. Here is part of what I've learned:

· In 1982, Vanderbilt was not ranked among the top 25 universities in the nation. Today, we rank No. 22, according to the prestigious U.S. News & World Report survey.

· The University's endowment was $170 million in 1981; it has grown to just over $1 billion.

· Sponsored research has nearly quadrupled to $162 million.

· The number of full-time faculty has increased 24 percent, while full-time medical faculty has grown 63 percent.

· In addition to Vanderbilt's top 25 ranking, Peabody is ranked eighth in the nation among graduate and professional schools of education. Its program in special education is first in the nation and the program in educational administration is fifth best.
·
Vanderbilt Medical School ranks 14th; School of Law 16th; The Engineering School placed in the top 50 graduate engineering programs.
·
In addition, many distinguished new programs and centers of excellence have been added - far too many for me to recite them today.

It's obvious that Vanderbilt has made enormous progress in the past 14 or 15 years during Joe
Wyatt's tenure.

During this period, Chancellor Wyatt worked closely with Bronson Ingram and Pat Wilson. The work of these three men and those who supported them, have, in my opinion, changed Vanderbilt from a good university to a great university.

The contribution Bronson Ingram made is immeasurable. Raising more than $500 million in endowment funds is an accomplishment hard to imagine and hard to match. His untimely death was a shock to all of us. I am honored to be chosen as his successor, but will need the support of the entire Board of Trust and all of you if we are to maintain the momentum he established.

The future of
athletics at Vanderbilt

Now let me address my fourth point and a topic that has been much in the news lately: Vanderbilt athletics.

The debate has been very pointed: Does Vanderbilt care enough about athletics? Can we compete with the Oilers and other pro teams coming to Nashville? What is the future of athletics at Vanderbilt?

Before I go any further, let me first congratulate Coach Jan van Breda Kolff, Coach Jim Foster and the basketball teams - men and women - for their fine seasons this year. I think we can all be proud of their accomplishments. I also want to give a special thanks to Rod Dowhower for our fifth straight football victory over Kentucky. Being surrounded in Ashland by many UK graduates, I cannot tell you how much I enjoyed our first win of the 1995 season.

As for the future of athletics at Vanderbilt, let me remind you that last April Chancellor Wyatt appointed and the Board of Trust approved an athletic committee to review all aspects of the program. Tom Frist and I were appointed co-chairmen, and we were joined by several other members of the Board.

Since then, the committee has devoted countless hours to analyzing Vanderbilt athletics and comparing our program to others around the nation. We have visited Duke, Wake Forest, Northwestern, Washington University in St. Louis, Georgia Tech and Tulane.

We have interviewed hundreds of people, including representatives of the alumni, news media, students, faculty and school administration. We have tried to take an objective view and look at what is best for Vanderbilt.

Our report is almost finished, but it is subject to review and approval by the Board at its April 26 meeting. As you know, the press obtained confidential information regarding our report, and a series of articles appeared early last week in both local papers. Chancellor Wyatt subsequently issued a statement to the Vanderbilt community, which was also made public.

The information in the articles and Chancellor Wyatt's statement is basically correct. We expect to make the report public within the next few days, but I must again caution you that no recommendations will be final until approved by the Board April 26. I'm optimistic that a good solution to the future of the athletics program at Vanderbilt will come out of that meeting. However, if the Board approves the recommendations, our work will have just begun as we start on the long road of implementation.

Nashville is
important to Vanderbilt

I said earlier that Vanderbilt is a great university, and we will continue to strive to maintain that position. However, we also know that your reputation at home follows you everywhere, and it is very important to Vanderbilt to have an outstanding relationship with the Nashville community. We do not believe that Vanderbilt's goal of being a great national university and its desire to serve Nashville and our alumni are mutually exclusive objectives.

We've had a great relationship in the past, and I believe we can in the future despite a few bumps in the road recently. I know Joe Wyatt is looking forward to leading the Nashville Chamber of Commerce this year and welcomes the opportunity to work closely with the Nashville business community. Through this work, I believe we will gain an even better understanding of one another and how we can work together for the good of everyone.

Chancellor Wyatt and I are also having an outside review performed to determine how we might strengthen communications with all constituents in Nashville and Middle Tennessee. We hope this effort will identify additional opportunities for a great community and a great university to work together.

Working together for the good of Nashville and Vanderbilt

In closing, thank you for the opportunity to be here today and allowing me to reminisce a bit about my ties to Nashville and Vanderbilt. I hope I have given you a better understanding of Vanderbilt, its challenges and its opportunities. I also hope I've given you a better appreciation of the enormous progress Vanderbilt has made in recent years, progress that we believe will continue in the future. Finally, I hope you understand how important Nashville is to Vanderbilt, and how important we believe it is for Nashville and Vanderbilt to have an outstanding relationship.

To the extent my job permits, I am trying to spend a few days every month in Nashville. I invite all of you to please feel free to contact me if you have any advice, comments, or questions. We want your input. No one is more important to Vanderbilt than our Nashville alumni and friends.

Today I represent Chancellor Wyatt and 11,000 Vanderbilt faculty and staff in extending my hand to you. We want Vanderbilt to be a great university, but we recognize greatness begins at home. We want to join you in making Nashville an outstanding community, and we hope you will join hands with us in working for the good of Nashville and Vanderbilt. We need your help and support.


Back to the Register

Vanderbilt Office of News and Public Affairs
HTML Translation by Billy Kingsley
Document last updated Jan. 10, 1997