MUSL 242: Notker Balbulus and the Sequence

Created by Mona Patel on February 13, 1998


Notker Balbulus ("the stammerer," ca. 840-912), a monk of the abbey of St. Gall in eastern Switzerland, was an author, a poet, a theorist, and a composer. Among his works are some accounts of the lives of saints (including that of St. Gall himself); an idealized history of Charlemagne; poems; letters; and a book entitled the Liber hymnorum (Book of Hymns, ca. 880), from which a general picture of the early sequence may be drawn. His abbey was one of the most prominent and influential monasteries in Europe in the ninth and tenth centuries; it's library contained some of the most important sources for the history of music, including the ancient and precious manuscripts of the Gregorian chant.

Gregorian Chants were sung as part of the Mass. Among the plainchants included in the Catholic Mass was the Alleluia, which is a responsorial chant (in which a soloist alternates with a choir) containing an extended melisma on the final "a" of alleluia called the jubilus. In a melisma a long melodic passage coincides with a single syllable (in this case the "a"). These melismas were extremely lengthy and complicated to remember; in order to better retain these long wordless melodies in memory Notker supplied them with words (in the ninth century). He explained the origin of these sequences in the Preface to his Liber hymnorum;, which gives evidence that Notker developed the sequences of his book under influence of the Antiphony of a monk of the Abbey of Jumieges.

Gradually these new insertions to the Alleluia were extended as new music and new words were added until the sequence totally detached itself from the Alleluia chant and became a separate part in the liturgy. This addition to the liturgy became a standard feature of the medieval Mass. However, the sequence was at least in some sense a part of the Alleluia that preceded it since it took the place of the final repetition of the respond at the end of the Alleluia (instead of the earlier form of Alleluia/jubilus-Verse-Alleluia/jubilus, the addition resulted in the following form: Alleluia-Verse-Sequence).

Contrasting the melismatic setting of the jubilus, Notker syllabically set his sequences so that each syllable corresponded to a single note. This characteristic of the sequence typified the tenth to twelfth century emphasis on a syllabic style and clear melodic goals. He wrote the sequences so that the text and the melody existed in a relationship in which two consecutive lines of text were set to the same phrase of music, forming a prose couplet. The entire sequence consists of a series of these couplets. Usually, the piece began and ended with a single line framing the couplets (resulting in an A BB CC...N form). The two texts of a couplet had the same number of syllables and pattern of accents. The specific lengths of the lines and the number of lines varied for each piece.

In addition, while it was possible to have multiple texts set to a single melody, only one melody could be found to fit any given text (since the melody was established before the text in these cases). This quality is historically important because it is therefore possible to obtain the plan of a melody from one of its texts without having the melody itself. The following two sections (the first five lines) from two of Notker's sequences demonstrate the form of the sequence as well as the correspondences of two different texts to the same melody/melodic pattern:

SANCTI BAPTISTAE (lined and broken in to syllables for easier visualization)
1) Sanc-ti bap-ti-stae Chri-sti prae-co-nis
2a)so-lem-ni- a ce- le-bran-tes mo-ri-bus ip- sum se-qua-mur
2b)Ut ad vi-amquam pre-dix-it as-se-clas su-os per-du- cat
3a)De-vo- ti te, sanc-tis-si-me ho-mi-num a-mi-ce- Je- se Chri-sti,
3b)Ap-pa-rens quae Za-cha-ri-ae Ga-bri-hel re-pro-mi-sit,qui tu- am
3a continued)fla-gi-ta-mus, ut gau-di-a per-ci-pi-a-mus...
3b continued)ce-le-bra-rent ob-se-qui-is na- ti-vi-ta-tem...
(Compared to) LAUS TIBI CHRISTE CUI SAPIT
1) Laus ti-bi Chri-ste
2a)cu-i sa-pit, quod vi-de-tur ce- te-ris es- se sur- da-strum:
2b)Fa-mu-la-tu cu-jus om-nis com-pe-tit sex-us et ae- tas.
3a)Re-cen-tes at- que te-ne-re mi-li-tes He-ro-di-a-no en-se
3b)Li-cet nec-dum po-tu-e-rint li-gu-la, ef- fu-si- o-ne ta-men
3a continued)tru-ci- da- ti, te ho- di- e prae-di-ca-ve-runt...
3b continued)te, Chri-ste,su-i san-gui-nis prae-co-na-ti sunt...

As stated by Crocker, the melodies Notker used for the sequences in his Liber Hymnorum can be divided into three groups (although each sequence has some distinguishing features that can be noticed only by studying each piece individually):


The works contained in Notker's Liber Hymnorum are important in musicology and in the study of early sequence. Notker has proven to be a significant exhibition that the early medieval artist is not necessarily anonymous. His book helps to date the included melodies to have existed at least before 900. According to Crocker, Notker's book is the most substantial piece of evidence for sequences as well as almost any other category of medieval chant.

Cecil Gray, in The History of Music, claims that the sequences "reveal a distinct approach to modern music, not only in the feeling for tonality, but also in the appearance of symmetrical repetitions of phrases, wide melodic leaps, and a more definitely rhythmical structure than is to be found elsewhere." Gray discusses Notker's sequences to have a significant impact in the history of medieval literature by bringing into "poetic art the new accential principle and to undermine and destroy the old classical verse meters." This aspect could also be significant in the gradual development of notation. What apparently originated as a method for singers to remember the difficult melismas over time grew and developed into an important part of musical history. The impact of Notker's sequence strongly exists in musicology and in the evolution of music itself.


The following are texts which are helpful in the study of Notker Balbulus and the Medieval Sequence:


The following are links to sites that relate to Notker and the Medieval Sequence:

The Three Monks of St. Gall
Notker Balbulus
Biographies
Notker the Stammerer
[Medieval Music]inactive link

The following are links to Vanderbilt University and various other resources:

MUSL242 Gateway Page
Dr. Cyrus's Early Music Links
Blair School of Music
Vanderbilt University Home Page


Send comments to:patelmp@ctrvax.vanderbilt.edu