Tae Bo:

Fitness Craze or Effective Workout?

Natalie Greer

Whatís all the fuss about?

Tae Bo, a form of high impact aerobics that combines the moves of Tae Kwon

Do, karate, boxing, ballet, and hip_hop dancing is the newest craze in gyms

and homes across the country. Tae Bo, which stands for Total Awareness

Excellent Body Obedience, was developed by Billy Blanks in the late 1980ís.

Blanks, a seven_time world karate champion and black belt in six martial

arts, developed Tae Bo in the basement of his home. Atfter encouragement

from family and friends, The Blankís World Training Center in Sherman Oaks,

CA was opened, introducing Tae Bo to local townspeople and limited Hollywood

celebrities. By word of mouth, Tae Bo gradually gained popularity, itsí fame

peaking with the release of the video package in August of 1998.

The four tape video package includes an instructional video, basic

workout, advanced workout, and an eight_minute workout. The videos are

commonly featured on a late night infomercial where the package can be

purchased for three payments of $19.95. The infomercial, featuring

testimonials from successful users, and a motivational speech from Blanks

himself, has sold over one million copies since 1998. "If youíve got the

will__Tae Boís the way" promises the announcer, for thousands of users this

seems to be the truth.

Troy Obrero , a well educated personal trainer in San Francisco, CA gives

Tae Bo his approval: "Tae Bo is an excellent cardiovascular workout with very

good distractions." Obrero targets lack of variety as the reason for failure

of many workout regimens, he claims that Tae Bo provides the necessary

novelty and challenge to keep users hooked. Very few people have done the

type of movements done in Tae Bo on a regular basis, continues Obrero, this

leads to its extreme effectiveness in toning and defining the entire body.

Blanks encourages his clients to work on their bodies from the inside

out; he claims: "results are imminent from the very first Tae Bo workout, as

completing it makes you feel great about yourself." Overall Blanks says his

Tae Bo workouts can improve balance, coordination, flexibility, and will tone

and define muscles. The workout regimen is exhaustively aerobic and

therefore yields phenomenal cardiovascular benefits. Finally, perhaps the

most appealing aspect of a Tae Bo workout is itsí proven calorie burning

effectiveness. An hour long Tae Bo workout will burn 500 to 800 calories,

compared with the 300 to 400 calories burned with a more conventional

aerobics class.

Testimonials

The world wide web is full of glowing recommendations from faithful Tae

Bo users. Although the workout seems to be most popular with women in their

twenties and early thirties, Blanks claims that Tae Bo is a great workout for

males and females of all ages. The following are examples of Tae Bo success

stories:

Linda Maricle from Pekins, South Carolina is a 38 year old mother of 16

year old twins. She has been doing Tae Bo with her boys for several months.

Maricle attributes her improved coordination and toned body to the Tae Bo

video library. "Tae Bo is so hard that you get quite a feeling of

accomplishment just by finishing."

Carol Ricci, 45, of Egg Harbor City, NJ, has dropped one dress size

since beginning Tae Bo. "I have noticed greater muscle definition; biceps,

shoulders, abdominal, and glutes since incorporating Tae Bo into my

workouts. It is really challenging, and I can see progress from workout to

workout."

Kristen Dollard, 26, has had great success with Tae Bo. "I was

desperate because I had tried everything and nothing worked__until Tae Bo. I

lost 45 pounds and 33 inches (overall) and have maintained it for a year!"

Lauren Sacks, 31, has also caught the Tae Bo bug. "Bring Billy Blanks

into your living room and youíll find a whole new thing that you never knew

existed. Once you try this youíll never go back to anything else and youíll

never quit."

Precautions__Is Tae Bo for everyone?

According to the American Council on Exercise (ACE) which serves as a

consumer watchdog on exercise products and programs, to prevent injury,

beginners should take precautions when beginning Tae Bo and other kick_boxing

workouts. ACE advises that potential Tae Bo users should achieve a solid

fitness foundation before beginning their workouts as even basic classes or

videos require above average endurance, flexibility, and strength. Once a

reasonable level of fitness has been achieved, beginners should be sure to

master proper technique before starting a full fledge workout. Common

beginnerís mistakes include overextending and locking joints when punching or

kicking which can result in painful muscle damage.

Kathy Smith, a well known aerobics instructor and fitness expert,

recently began taking kick_boxing classes. Although Smith has boxed for

years and is in excellent shape, she found the workout incredibly strenuous.

"For the first two weeks, every muscle ached and my back felt miserable. I

began to wonder whether kick_boxing is more of a workout than many people

might be able to handle." Kick_boxing places stresses and strains on the

body that are much more severe than those endured during a more traditional

aerobic workout. Tae Bo newcomers often start out too hard and too fast,

putting too much stress on their joints and surrounding tissue which can lead

to injuries. Smith cautions that those who have been sedentary, especially

if theyíre over 30 or overweight, should proceed slowly for at least eight

weeks.

Finally, although the martial art undertones are what help make Tae Bo

such an effective cardiovascular workout, Troy Obrero believes this leads

many people to falsely assume that they are learning a martial art. "Nothing

could be further from the truth" cautions Obrero; Tae Bo is not a

self-defense course and practitioners should not attempt to use the

techniques outside of their workouts.

The Scientific Evidence

Although it is widely accepted that physical activity is imperative for

achieving good health and fitness, the type of exercise recommended has been

a topic of intense debate. High impact exercise is characterized by the

stress it places on the body and usually involves bouncing and jolting; low

impact exercise is much easier on the body but tends to be a less efficient

calorie burner. Low impact exercise has often been suggested as a safer,

user friendly way for people of all shapes and sizes to get and stay in

shape. Despite the risk factors, high impact exercise is widely practiced,

as evidenced by the popularity of the Tae Bo program. Do the stresses Tae Bo

places on the body outweigh itís extreme calorie burning effectiveness? Is

Tae Bo safe for everyone, or just for the small minority of the population

who can be considered "in shape"? For the answers to these and other related

questions, we turn to the scientific literature.

Although no studies have been performed on Tae Bo specifically, evidence

can be extrapolated from studies on strenuous and high impact exercise. One

such study sought to determine the long term pattern of relaxation times and

muscle volume changes in human skeletal muscle after intense exercise (Foley

et al., 1999). Six young adult men performed two bouts of eccentric bicep

curls separated by eight weeks. Blood samples, soreness ratings, and

magnetic resonance imaging of the muscles were taken immediately before and

after each bout of exercise and at varying intervals throughout the eight

weeks. Results of the MRI showed a gradual increase in total volume of the

imaged arm after bout one, but volume returned to pre_exercise values within

two weeks. The exercised flexor compartment swelled by over 40%, but after

two weeks reverted to a volume 10% smaller than pre_exercise values and

maintained this volume through eight weeks post_exercise. This suggests

complete or partial destruction of a small sub_population of muscle fibers,

resulting in a slight loss of strength and extension in the exercised arm.

After bout two, pain ratings and muscle swelling were significantly lower;

this supports the idea of a repeated_bout effect, in which a muscle adapts to

protect itself from further damage.

Applied to Tae Bo, which when done incorrectly can result in the

eccentric extension of a number of muscle groups, this study seems to support

the precautions expressed in other less scientific literature. If done

incorrectly Tae Bo can produce extensive long lasting muscle damage, by

proceeding slowly and focusing on technique however, these effects can be

minimized. The repeated_bout effect mentioned in this study would suggest

that by performing the same exercises at regular intervals, the body will

slowly adjust until the soreness and swelling initially produced begin to

disappear.

Strenuous exercise is followed by a decreased concentration of

lymphocytes and impaired natural immunity; the findings on this topic were

compiled in a article by Pederson et al. in 1999. Regular lower impact

exercise may increase resistance to infections, while strenuous exercise is

associated with increased respiratory tract infections. Lymphocyte

concentration increases during exercise and falls below pre_exercise values

following intense long duration exercise, this accounts for the so called

"open window" of altered immunity. Findings on exercise in the elderly show

an overall decline in the immunity to infection, especially as related to

strenuous exercise. It has been found however, that the immune system of

older individuals can respond to the stress imposed by a single bout of

exercise.

Various nutritional supplements have been tested for their effectiveness

in eliminating post_exercise altered immunity. The most effective of these

supplements was carbohydrates. Compared with placebo, the ingestion of

carbohydrates before, during, and after strenuous exercise was found to

diminish the negative immune response in some studies. An advanced Tae Bo

workout could be considered strenuous exercise, especially for beginners and

those who are not frequent exercisers. These findings suggest that Tae Bo

practitioners should take extra care to avoid increasing their susceptibility

to infections. Proper nutrition, as well as carbohydrate supplementation,

should be used to combat these possible negative effects.

A review of six case studies warns experimenters against the use of

eccentric exercise protocols to induce and study mild forms of muscle

damage. In two different studies involving a total of 231 subjects, maximal

eccentric actions of the elbow flexors were used. Each subject performed two

sets of 25 actions, separated by a five minute rest period. In these two

studies a total of 8 adverse events occurred in which subjects experienced

extreme swelling and prolonged loss in the ability of the muscle to generate

force. At itsí worst, the size of the affected arm was approximately twice

the size of the normal arm. Normal recovery time of force generation

following eccentric exercise is two weeks, in these cases however, subjects

showed losses of up to 47 days in the ability of the muscle to generate

force. These symptoms are consistent with a condition called

rhabdomyolysis. Rhabdomyolysis is defined as a degeneration of muscle cells

following strenuous, overexertion exercise, and is characterized by muscle

tenderness, weakness, swelling, dark urine, and increased levels of muscle

proteins in the blood. With dehydration or heat stress, myoglobin can

precipitate in the kidneys and cause renal failure.

Although none of the six cases reviewed appeared to meet all the

diagnosing criteria for rhabdomyolysis, it should be recognized that only one

muscle group was involved. Such exercise involving several muscle groups

could be dangerous. Although in general, high_force eccentric exercise poses

little threat to otherwise healthy individuals with no history of

musculoskeletal disease or injury, this study showed a 3% incidence of

extreme negative responses to such exercises. This study provides further

evidence that the highest precautions should be taken to avoid muscle damage

with high impact exercises such as Tae Bo.

When performed carefully and correctly high impact exercise does have

positive effects, especially in younger participants. A study of 71

premenarcheal girls, 9_10 years old, explored the lean mass, strength, and

bone mineral response to a ten month high impact strength_building exercise

program (Morris et al., 1997). The girls were divided into experimental and

control groups, at baseline these groups did not differ in height, total body

mass, pubertal development, calcium intake, or external physical activity.

After ten months, the exercise group gained significantly more lean mass,

less body fat content, greater shoulder, knee and grip strength, and

increased levels of bone mineral content as compared with the control group.

These results suggest that high impact, strength building exercise, such as

Tae Bo, is beneficial for increasing strength, lean mass gains, and bone

mineral acquisition in premenarcheal girls. This finding is especially

important, as the enhancement of bone mineral acquisition during growth is

thought to help prevent osteoporosis.

A study by Bassey, Rothwell, Littlewood, and Pye (1998), suggests that

the positive effects of high impact exercise on bone mineral density found in

young girls do not apply to older, post_menopausal women. Randomized

controlled trials were used in both pre_ and post_menopausal women to assess

the effects of a vertical jumping exercise regime on bone mineral density.

The exercise consisted of 50 vertical jumps with a mean height of 8.5 cm on

six days per week. After five months, pre_menopausal women showed a

significant increase in femoral bone mineral density, while at both 12 and 18

months post_menopausal women showed no difference in bone mineral density

when compared with controls. It appears that pre_menopausal women respond

positively to brief high impact exercise but post_menopausal women do not.

For this reason, as well as the other risks associated with high impact

exercise, older women may benefit more from regular low impact exercise than

from a high impact workout such as Tae Bo.

A final study of interest compared the exercise intensity and rating of

perceived exertion of a high impact and low impact university aerobic dance

session (Grant, Davidson, Aitchison, and Wilson, 1998). Ten women with a

mean age of 22.6 years were randomly assigned to high impact and low impact

sessions; heart rate, oxygen uptake, and rating of perceived exertion were

measured throughout each session. All three of these measures were

consistently higher during the high impact session than during the low impact

session. For the participants of this study, all young fit females, high

impact exercise has the potential to maintain or improve aerobic fitness,

while low impact activity has a limited training effect and may actually

result in detraining for some individuals. Consistent with previous

research, this study suggests that low impact activities may be an

appropriate mode of exercise for unfit and overweight individuals, while

higher impact activities will benefit individuals who have already achieved a

reasonable level of fitness.

The Bottom Line

Tae Bo can be an effective and beneficial cardiovascular workout when

performed correctly by the right type of person. Individuals who do not

frequently exercise, are overweight, are over the age of 50, or have health

problems should opt for a lower impact form of exercise at least initially.

Tae Bo and other high impact exercises may lead to muscle damage, prolonged

loss of strength, decreased immune function, and in extreme cases

rhabdomyolysis. Susceptibilities to these negative consequences can all be

reduced however, if proper precautions are exercised. Even for those who are

extremely fit and active, unfamiliar exercise can cause damage. After

working to obtain a reasonable level of fitness, participants should begin

very slowly and master the basic Tae Bo maneuvers before participating in a

full length workout. To decrease the chances of muscle damage, participants

should work to maintain good flexibility, and perform specific warm_up and

cool_down exercises for the principal muscle groups (Mchugh, 1999). In

addition, participants should practice proper nutrition and supplement their

diets with additional carbohydrates before and after hard workouts.

When done properly, Tae Bo can increase lean body mass,

decrease body fat, improve coordination and flexibility, and in

some participants even increase the mineral content of the bones.

The novelty of Tae Bo can provide motivation and encourage

perseverance that may be absent with more traditional monotonous

workouts. So by all means, if youíre fit, healthy, and up for a

challenge, join the nearly two million other Americans who have

jumped on the Tae Bo bandwagon, just donít expect to be kicking

like Billy Blanks for quite some time.

References

Bassey, E., Rothwell, M., Littlewood, J., & Pye, D. (1998). Pre_ and

post_menopausal women have different bone mineral density responses to the

same high_impact exercise. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 13(12),

1805_1813.

Foley, J., Jayaraman, R, Prior, B., Pivarnik, J., & Meyer, R. (1999). MR

measurements of muscle damage and adaptation after eccentric exercise,

Journal of Applied Physiology, 87(6), 2311_2318.

Grant, S., Davidson, W., & Wilson, J. (1998) A comparison of physiological

responses and rating of perceived exertion between high_impact and

low_impact aerobic dance sessions. European Journal of Applied Physiology

and Occupational Physiology, 78(4), 324_332.

McHugh, Mal. (1999) Can exercise induced muscle damage be avoided? The

British Journal of Sports Medicine, 33(6), 377.

Morris, F., Naughton, G., Gibbs, J., Carlson, J., & Wark, J. (1997).

Prospective ten_month exercise intervention in premenarcheal girls: Positive

effects on bone and lean mass. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, 12(9),

1453_1462.

Pedersen, B., Bruunsgaard, H., Jensen, M., Krzywkowski, K., & Ostrowski, K.

(1999). Exercise and immune function: effect of aging and nutrition.

Proceedings of the Nutrition Society, 58, 733_742.

Sayers, S., Clarkson, P., Rouzier, P., & Kamen, G. (1999). Adverse events

associated with eccentric exercise protocols: six case studies. Medicine and

Science in Sports and Exercise, 31(12), 1697_1702.

http://www.myria.com/self/fitness/taebo.htm

http://www.of_the_world.com/taebo/testimonials2.htm

http://www.taebo.com/main.html

http://146.186.194.36/archive/1999/04/04_14_99tdc/04_14_99dsports_8.asp

http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?TS=9...=3&Sid=1&Idx=4&Deli=1&RQT =309&Dtp=1

http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?TS=9...=3&Sid=4&Idx=6&Deli=1&RQT =309&Dtp=1

 

Psychology Department

The Health Psychology Home Page is produced and maintained by David Schlundt, PhD.
  


Vanderbilt Homepage | Introduction to Vanderbilt | Admissions | Colleges & Schools | Research Centers | News & Media Information | People at Vanderbilt | Libraries | Administrative Departments | Medical 

  Return to the Health Psychology Home Page
  Send E-mail comments or questions to Dr. Schlundt

Search

Search: Vanderbilt University
the Internet

  Help  Advanced

Tip: You can refine your last query by searching only the results by clicking on the tab above the search box

Having Trouble Reading this Page?  Download Microsoft Internet Explorer.